Amerikali filozof Robert Nozick'in olum yildonumu (23 Ocak 2002)
"Eger diger kisi bir suc islemisse, tabiat halinde yasayan herkesin bu kisiyi cezalandirmaya hakki yok mudur? Bana oyle geliyor ki, burada haklara yonelik farkli degerlendirmelerin nasil butunlestirilebilecegi konusunda terminolojik bir mesele ile karsi karsiyayiz. Bir kisinin, belli gercekleri bilmedigi takdirde bazi seyleri yapmaya hakki olmadigini mi soyleyecegiz, yoksa hakki oldugunu fakat belli gercekleri bilmeden yaptigi takdirde hata yapmis olacagini mi soyleyecegiz?" Anarsi, Devlet ve Utopya
"If the other has committed a crime, doesn't everyone in a state of nature have a right to punish him? And therefore doesn't someone who doesn't know that this other person has committed the crime? Here, it seems to me, we face a terminological issue about how to merge epistemic considerations with rights. Shall we say that someone doesn't have a right to do certain things unless he knows certain facts, or shall we say that he does have a right but hedoes wrong in exercising it unless he knows certain facts?"


Alıntı yaparak yanıtla




Yer İmleri